Taylor Swift Sparks Controversy: Fans React to 1830s Comment on ‘The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology’

Taylor Swift Faces Criticism Over Lyrics in ‘The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology’

Taylor Swift’s latest album, “The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology,” has sparked controversy with one particular lyric that has drawn criticism from fans and observers alike. In the track “I Hate It Here,” Taylor Swift sings about her discontent with the current era and expresses a desire to live in the 1830s, albeit “without all the racists.” This lyric has elicited strong reactions due to its apparent oversight of the realities of slavery during that period.

Swift’s lyric, “I’d say the 1830s but without all the racists,” has been met with backlash on social media, with many pointing out the historical context of the 1830s in America, where slavery was legalized and racial discrimination was rampant. Fans were quick to highlight the glaring omission of acknowledging the atrocities of slavery while expressing a desire to live in that time period.

Taylor Swift mentions her fanbase in new lyrics to ‘I Hate It Here’:

“I'd say the 1830s but without all the racists and getting married off for the highest bid”. pic.twitter.com/do0TaxMORL

— Pob Base (@PobBase) April 19, 2024

One Twitter user expressed disbelief at Swift’s remark, questioning the casual manner in which she addressed the issue of racism and slavery: “There is no way Taylor Swift said she’d like to live in an era where Chattel Slavery was the law of the land and say ‘but without the racists.’ Like it was some casual microaggressions or something. Is this what we’re doing??”

Others echoed similar sentiments, criticizing Swift’s choice of time period and highlighting the significance of slavery in shaping the socio-political landscape of the 1830s. Another user commented, “Pretty astonishing to stipulate that she wants to live in the 1830s, ‘except without the racists,’ and not mention slavery, so slavery still exists but everyone’s chill about it.”

The controversy surrounding Swift’s lyric has reignited discussions about historical awareness and sensitivity in songwriting, particularly when addressing sensitive topics such as racism and slavery. Critics argue that Swift’s portrayal of the 1830s overlooks the harsh realities faced by marginalized communities during that period, undermining the severity of systemic oppression.

There is no way Taylor Swift said she’d like to live in an era where Chattel Slavery was the law of the land and say “but without the racists”. Like it was some casual microaggressions or something. Is this what we’re doing??

— she better be coming… (@CannyZanny) April 19, 2024

In addition to the backlash over the 1830s lyric, Taylor Swift’s album also contains references to her ongoing feud with Kim Kardashian, as well as nods to her past relationships and current beau Travis Kelce. While Swift’s lyrics have often been praised for their emotional depth and storytelling prowess, the controversy surrounding this particular lyric underscores the importance of thoughtful and responsible storytelling in music.

As discussions continue to unfold online, Taylor Swift and her team have yet to respond to the criticism. However, the backlash serves as a reminder of the power of music to provoke meaningful dialogue and reflection on complex social issues.

I mention Taylor Swift once for a joke and now I'm getting news about her, and I gotta say: pretty astonishing to stipulate that she wants to live in the 1830s, "except without the racists," and not mention slavery, so slavery still exists but everyone's chill about it

— ★ (@corpseinorbit) April 19, 2024

Taylor Swift says she wants to go back to the 1830s and she’s celebrated.

I say I want to go back to 1830s and I’m put on the FBI’s watchlist

— Cody (@AltHistCody) April 19, 2024

I know I can’t stfu abt Taylor Swift but of all time periods WHY THE 1830s??? The most notable event from the time period is the trail of tears like I cannot wrap my head around it? Is this another one of her dumbass codes?

— sam? (@samhcarr0ll) April 19, 2024

Taylor Swift wanting to go back to the 1830s surprised no Black person anywhere.

— Jenn M. Jackson, PhD (they/them) (@JennMJacksonPhD) April 19, 2024

Taylor Swift talking with other white women when she goes back to the 1830s pic.twitter.com/heh2WdgqGn

— Meech (@MediumSizeMeech) April 19, 2024

• Also read: Drake Fires Shots at Kendrick Lamar and Taylor Swift in Diss Tracks ‘Push Ups’ and ‘Taylor Made Freestyle’