Andrew Scott Shuts Down Taylor Swift ‘Tortured Poets’ Fan Theories Amid Group Chat Controversy

Andrew Scott has put an end to the swirling fan theories linking Taylor Swift’s album title, “The Tortured Poets Department,” to the infamous “Tortured Man Club” group chat he shared with Paul Mescal and Swift’s ex, Joe Alwyn.

Swifties have been buzzing with speculation ever since the announcement of Swift’s 11th album, drawing connections between the WhatsApp chat and the album’s theme. However, Andrew Scott has stepped in to provide some clarity, revealing that he initiated the group chat to connect Joe Alwyn and Paul Mescal as they prepared to play “tortured characters” in their respective projects.

Setting the record straight in a recent interview with Variety, Andrew Scott emphasized that the group chat wasn’t about their personal traits but rather about their roles as actors. Despite the initial intention, the chat didn’t sustain much activity, fizzling out after just a few messages.

This revelation comes after a 2022 Actors on Actors interview with Joe Alwyn and Paul Mescal, where they humorously acknowledged their former group chat’s inactivity. Their comments at the time hinted at the casual nature of the chat and its eventual decline.

Joe Alwyn and Paul Mescal have a WhatsApp group with Andrew Scott called "The Tortured Man Club."

"It hasn't had much use recently," Alwyn says.
"I feel like we're less tortured now," Mescal quips. https://t.co/CSai4ScQpz pic.twitter.com/veCp1ZdFsD

— Variety (@Variety) December 15, 2022

Taylor Swift’s dedicated fanbase, known for their keen attention to detail, has shown unwavering support for the singer, even flocking to a London pub mentioned in her album. The venue, referenced in track 17 of Swift’s double album release, reportedly faced an influx of fans, leading to overcrowding and the need to turn away customers.

Among Taylor Swift’s fans, there has been speculation that the song referencing the London pub delves into the intricacies of her past relationship with Joe Alwyn. However, Scott’s recent clarification sheds light on the group chat’s origins, redirecting the focus away from personal narratives and back to their professional collaborations.

As the buzz surrounding Swift’s album continues to captivate fans, Scott’s insights serve as a reminder to approach fan theories with a critical eye, emphasizing the importance of understanding the context behind celebrity interactions and projects.

• Also read: Britney Spears Opens Up About Serious Nerve Damage